Comparing Wealth Build-up in Traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA: Is Having $1.8M in Traditional IRA and $300K in Roth IRA an Optimal Retirement Savings Strategy?

Retiring Wisely: A Comprehensive Guide to Withdrawing from Traditional IRA and Social Security

Retiring with a substantial wealth is a dream for many. However, managing these funds wisely to ensure a comfortable retirement is a challenge that many retirees face. A Redditor, in their mid-50s, with an impressive portfolio of $10.4 million, comprising of a $6.3 million brokerage account, a $1.8 million traditional IRA, and a $300k Roth account, is seeking advice on the most optimal way to withdraw from their retirement accounts. In this post, we’ll discuss the Redditor’s situation and suggest some strategies.

Starting with the Traditional IRA

When the Redditor makes withdrawals, it’s recommended to start with the traditional IRA. Although these withdrawals are taxed, the Redditor can withdraw funds when they retire to lower their tax bill. This strategy also protects the brokerage account and Roth IRA. Traditional IRAs don’t qualify for step-up basis when passed on to heirs, but the children will likely earn income from jobs or businesses, which will put them in higher tax brackets. The Redditor calculated that they need to withdraw $267k per year to support their lifestyle. Most of these funds should come from a traditional IRA when it’s time to withdraw from the account.

Planning Long-Term Finances: Human Touch Still Matters

The Redditor was also looking for software to plan out their withdrawals over the long run. While some recommend Boldin and other tools, relying solely on software to plan out long-term finances might not be the best idea. The tax landscape is constantly changing, and the U.S. leadership’s policies can significantly impact retirement planning. President Biden’s administration’s proposed tax changes and potential elimination of income taxes could lead to a year-to-year planning process.

Delaying Social Security Payments

The Redditor is considering taking out Social Security upon turning 62, which would net them $36k per year. However, there are risks involved in this strategy since the Social Security income can push the Redditor into a higher tax bracket. Furthermore, the benefits grow each year if the Redditor waits. The Redditor mentioned their family’s relatively short life expectancy as one reason to tap into Social Security now instead of at 70. However, people are living longer these days, and waiting until their mid to late 60s could result in a larger benefit.

Impact on Individuals

For individuals planning their retirement, the Redditor’s situation highlights the importance of careful planning and considering various strategies to optimize retirement income. Delaying Social Security payments, starting with the traditional IRA, and being aware of changing tax landscape are some key takeaways. It’s essential to consult a financial advisor to create a personalized retirement plan that suits your unique financial situation.

Impact on the World

From a broader perspective, the Redditor’s case underscores the importance of understanding the potential impact of political and economic changes on retirement planning. As the world’s population ages, retirement planning becomes an increasingly crucial issue. Governments and financial institutions need to adapt to the changing demographic landscape and provide effective tools and resources to help individuals plan for their retirement years.

In conclusion, the Redditor’s story serves as a reminder that careful planning and considering various strategies are essential when withdrawing from retirement accounts. Starting with the traditional IRA, delaying Social Security payments, and being aware of the changing tax landscape are some key takeaways for individuals planning their retirement. Furthermore, the Redditor’s case highlights the importance of understanding the potential impact of political and economic changes on retirement planning. By taking a deliberate and informed approach, individuals can ensure they have a comfortable and secure retirement.

  • Starting with the traditional IRA is a good strategy to lower your tax bill and protect your brokerage account and Roth IRA.
  • Consider delaying Social Security payments to maximize benefits.
  • Be aware of the changing tax landscape and its impact on retirement planning.
  • Consult a financial advisor for personalized retirement planning advice.

Remember, everyone’s financial situation is unique, and it’s crucial to tailor retirement planning to your specific needs and goals. Stay informed and plan wisely for a comfortable and secure retirement.

Leave a Reply